Waterstones censors academics launching book on Labour and antisemitism
STOP PRESS: 27th September.
Waterstone’s admits: “We made a mistake.” James Daunt says “”I acknowledge that the cancellation of the event was not actually necessary”. There was no intention to repress free speech…
H/t Steve Tiller
Scholars forced to abandon the launch at Waterstones in Brighton of a book about Labour and antisemitism have condemned an “astonishing attack on free speech and academic freedom” which resulted in the bookstore cancelling the planned event on Monday.
Jewish Voice for Labour has produced the following statement which is being distributed at Labour Party conference today, Tuesday September 24.
See here how to order the book in question, Bad News for Labour: Antisemitism, the Party and Public Belief.
Update: 26 September.
We post below our statement a Canary report Waterstones shuts down book launch exposing the antisemitism witch hunt against the left
Intimidation in Brighton
Waterstones bookshop in Brighton was due to host a publicly advertised launch of Bad News for Labour: Antisemitism, the Party and Public Belief, at 7.30 pm on Monday Sept 23. This is a scholarly book by renowned experts on how the media has influenced public perception of the party under Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership.
On Monday morning, publishers Pluto Press heard that, following “a barrage of abusive emails, phonecalls and tweets” aimed at the Brighton store, the event was to be cancelled.
The book’s authors – Professor Greg Philo, University of Glasgow; Dr Mike Berry, University of Cardiff; Antony Lerman, Senior Fellow, Bruno Kreisky Forum for International Dialogue, Vienna; Dr Justin Schlosberg, Birkbeck, University of London and Professor David Miller, University of Bristol – condemned “this … astonishing attack on free speech and academic freedom. To stop university teachers from discussing research evidence in a bookshop through intimidation is simply incredible.”
It was only thanks to the local Rialto theatre making space available at the last minute that the launch was able to go ahead. The Rialto has since suffered serious online abuse.
Local staff at Waterstones who wanted the launch to proceed were overruled by senior management to force cancellation of the event – an alarming capitulation to intimidation. This is the most shocking of a number of attacks on freedom of speech at this year’s conference, with a succession of venues cancelling bookings by left-wing, pro-Palestinian organisations after facing abuse and threats.
It is vital that public figures, on Brighton council, in the Labour party and elsewhere, speak out against this bullying behaviour. All progressive groups are vulnerable to intolerant and repressive attacks. From banning meetings and preventing book launches, it is a small step before we will see books being burned by people who disapprove of their content.
Protest to Waterstones’ management via their website, www.waterstones.com
Send any replies you receive to info@jvl.org.uk.
Waterstones shuts down book launch exposing the antisemitism witch hunt against the left
The Canary, 24 September 2019
A torrent of “threats” and ‘abuse’, allegedly levied against Waterstones in Brighton, resulted in the cancellation of a book launch on antisemitism and the Labour Party. Pluto Press and Waterstones announced that they were “delighted to host an event to mark the release of Bad News for Labour: Antisemitism, the Party and Public Belief” on 23 September. But the bookstore then updated its website to say: “Due to reasons out of our control we have had to cancel tonight’s event”. Organisers told The Canary this was down to a “harassment” campaign.
Independent publisher Pluto also released a statement expressing its ‘disappointment’ that “external pressure” had resulted in the cancellation of the event:
We are disappointed to announce that tonight’s launch for ‘Bad News for Labour’ has been cancelled by @Waterstones, Brighton due to external pressure put on the store… https://t.co/dhQdRu0DYm— Pluto Press (@PlutoPress) September 23, 2019
“A barrage of abusive emails, phone calls, and tweets”
Greg Philo, the lead author of the book, informed The Canary via Justin Schlosberg, also a co-author, that:
Pluto Press had been contacted by Waterstones head office the day before the event was scheduled and told that the Brighton store had received a barrage of abusive emails, phone calls and tweets about the event and that there had been intimidation in the Brighton store.
Philo explained:
Our book acknowledges the existence of antisemitism in the Labour Party but critically examines the degree to which people have been misinformed about its extent and the role of the leadership in dealing with it.
Waterstones denies threats and intimidation
The Canary received a response from Waterstones which offered a very different explanation for cancelling the event on the day:
I can confirm that we have cancelled today’s event. I would like to make clear that we did not receive threats or harassment. Here are some points to outline why we have made the decision.
- this was a small event with about 50 tickets sold
- it raised considerable emotion from various parties on both sides of the debate
- we do not wish to be caught in this debate at an especially emotive moment: it is not a debate from which we shy in terms of book stock but it is not one in which we wish to be perceived to have taken sides
- on a more practical level, we have not yet received the book stock and worried that it would not arrive in time
- the shop decided to cancel the event in discussion with the central events team
- we hope to reschedule the talk in this shop, or in others when we can be better prepared
Waterstones’ statement contradicted by the authors
But Schlosberg subsequently confirmed to The Canary that he was directly warned on Saturday that the event would likely be cancelled due to a “barrage” of “threats” and “harassment”.
David Miller, an academic with the University of Bristol and co-author of the book, also pushed back against Waterstones’ statement. He told The Canary “there were threats”. He also said “It’s not a debate. It is research findings”. Furthermore, he said the books arrived in Brighton at 2pm, well before the event was supposed to be held at 7.30pm. In fact, “the guy who arranged the event offered to come and sell the books personally”.
“Only one step from book burning”
Miller told The Canary: “It is really extraordinary that [this book event] has been cancelled as a result of threats”. He called it a “serious attack on both freedom of speech and academic freedom”.
Philo also hit the point home, noting that:
Academics from four universities are being stopped from discussing their research in a bookshop. It is only one step from burning books.
Organisers scheduled the event to occur on the evening of the third day of the Labour Party’s annual conference. Miller explained that “on arriving in Brighton at 12.37pm I got a message that people with tickets were in receipt of refunds”. This was a common theme. Andrew Feinstein, founder of Corruption Watch and author of The Shadow World: Inside The Global Arms Trade, told The Canary that he had been looking forward to attending the event “for a number of months”. He drove down to Brighton specially for the event and received an email at around 12.30pm refunding him for his ticket.
Andrew Feinstein: ‘This is personal to me as a Jew’
Feinstein explained that his “interest in the issue is born out of a number of factors”, including:
That I’m Jewish. That I’m a son of a holocaust survivor who lost 39 members of her family in the holocaust. That I was the first MP to introduce a motion in the South African Parliament, [which shockingly hadn’t occurred until his motion in 1996]. And that I’ve written about and lectured on genocide prevention at Auschwitz.
He called the alleged threats and harassment against Waterstones “absolutely despicable”.
Feinstein told The Canary:
In my opinion the whole discussion and debate has become completely irrational in the sense that this idea that the Labour Party has a particular antisemitism problem is simply not born out by the facts.
The ‘degeneration’ of discourse within parts of the Jewish community
He said that:
The irony of that is that the Jewish Community, throughout history, has been the source of such diverse intellectual and political thought and that debate has always been encouraged in the Jewish community – certainly in my experience. The fact that one can no longer discuss this issue – the fact that events are being cancelled – this intolerance and refusal to discuss issues properly is deeply deeply problematic.
Feinstein pointed out that “there are a number of levels at which the debate has degenerated”. He emphasised that:
nobody asks my opinion on Zionism. Its just the fact that I’m Jewish and I support Jeremy Corbyn – that is now somehow completely unacceptable to [certain] members of the Jewish community.
“Appalling Abuse” unleashed onto me as a “Jewish supporter of Jeremy Corbyn”
I’ve found as a Jewish supporter of Jeremy Corbyn the sort of abuse that is levelled at people like myself online is absolutely appalling. I’ve had the situation where I’ve mentioned my mother’s history, and a rabbi responded on social media suggesting that my mother must have been one of those Jews who collaborated with the Nazis – its insane and out of control. It really is.
He said he has found “absolutely no desire to engage on the matter”, and that:
Those propagating this notion of an antisemitism crisis in the Labour Party – they don’t want to hear anything different to their views.
Feinstein finds this “quite scary and deeply, deeply, problematic”.
Antisemitism is lower under Corbyn
He also pointed out that polling by YouGov on antisemitism in the UK and among political parties in 2015 and 2017 showed low levels of antisemitism within the Labour Party. He said the 2017 poll, after Corbyn had been leader for over a year, “showed antisemitism among Labour had fallen and was joint lowest among all political parties”.
Feinstein told The Canary:
I therefore believe that this whole crises has been manufactured by people who want to see Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership ended – and the irony of that is that Jeremy Corbyn is probably the most anti-racist politician of the last three and a bit decades in this country.
The Canary already reported how previous events, also to be held in Brighton with socialist MP Chris Williamson (himself a strong supporter of Palestinian rights), were also cancelled following a campaign of ‘intimidation and harassment’ unleashed onto staff at the Holiday Inn. A harassment campaign also reportedly led to the normally politically resilient Quakers pulling out as the back-up venue at the last minute.
But just as organisers persevered and found an alternative venue for the event with Williamson, so did the organisers of the launch of Bad News for Labour. They persisted, re-routed the books to the Rialto Theatre, and held a very successful book launch and discussion just around the corner. The attacks on the left in the UK are no joke, but neither is the resistance to them.
< a id="addition">
From: Daunt, James <James.Daunt@waterstones.com>
Date: Fri, 27 Sep 2019 at 10:20
Subject: FW: Suppression of Academic Free Speech
As a matter of fact, I was not personally involved in the decision to cancel the event. I was in London last Monday but in meetings and was not consulted. You are correct, however, that it was a decision taken in London by the central events team and overruled the wishes of the shop itself.
The reason was largely one of simple irritation at what was perceived to be an ill-prepared event. With the benefit of hindsight, the event could have proceeded. The books did arrive and the shop could have handled it sensibly.
Is this an egregious suppression of academic free speech? I think more a case of muddle and a hasty reaction based on annoyance that a cooler head and more mature response could have avoided.
The reaction in turn from a small number of members of the public has been very strong. I respect those who worry that Waterstones will not stock books that cover controversial topics and especially those that address the politics of Israel and Palestine, and assure you that this is not the case. We will continue to stock and promote books of this sort, and of course this specific title.
I do not respect – and in fact abhor – those who have used the incident to make virulently anti-Semitic comment, as I hope you will agree. I have been on the receiving end of some shocking interactions that are completely alien to me.
In summary, I acknowledge that the cancellation of the event was not actually necessary. The motivation to do so was not malicious, however, let alone driven by any particular political agenda or the result of any external pressure. We made a mistake.
Regards
James [Daunt]
Geen opmerkingen:
Een reactie posten
Opmerking: Alleen leden van deze blog kunnen een reactie posten.